It all seems like déjà vu for President Bill Clinton, after being back from North Korea after securing the releases of two South Korea journalists, the former President has now seen yet another fierce debate about universal healthcare which is going nowhere. In 1994, President Clinton's bill for universal healthcare failed to pass. The Democrats were hammered in the congressional elections, the Republicans, led by Newt Gingrich, gained a majority in both houses, and Clinton was seen as a one-termer.
Despite being the foremost economic power in the world, the United States still has millions of citizens without health insurance. Programs like Medicare and Medicaid have been failing and many Americans can't afford their healthcare - surely healthcare is a right, not a privelege? But how would universal healthcare fare in the USA?
A number of countries already have universal healthcare in place, take the National Health Service in the United Kingdom. The NHS, although a controversial organisation during its early years, has been supported by a large majority of British citizens after it's 60th anniversary last year. The National Health Service Act was passed in 1946 and came to being on July 5, 1948, in years after the Second World War. Members of the Labour Party have always hailed the Attlee government and Health Minister Nye Bevan for being the architects of the NHS, seen as one of the best healthcare systems worldwide. So if universal healthcare was around in Britain 60 years ago, why is America's healthcare still privatised?
Healthcare reform was one of President Obama's top domestic priorities during his 2008 campaign, and the President has said that it is his top priority for 2009, and indeed a debate has been called on universal healthcare. Although throughout the campaign he told Americans that they can keep their health insurance if they liked it, Obama faces a big roadblock in his campaign to make a "public option" available - Congress.
Thomas Jefferson once described the function of Congress to 'cool down' the executive. It is apparent that Congress has always been the force for status quo and the executive the force for action. Of course, within Congress there are those who would like to see a public option made available, on the liberal wing Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-MA), who is currently fighting a battle against brain cancer, and on the more conservative side the likes of Sen. Arlen Specter (D-PA), a new Democratic recruit after serving five terms as a Republican. However, on the whole, despite the best attempts made by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Congress has been reluctant to show full support to the bill.
President Obama has a clear majority in both chambers of Congress, and there are 60 members of the Democratic caucus in the Senate, enough to overide a filibuster from the GOP. President Clinton also had a majority, albeit smaller, during his efforts to reform healthcare in 1994. #42 failed, is #44 going to follow suit? While a majority in Congress is useful, it is not clear-cut, and bills driven through by the executive can always fall down. Major reform bills introduced by the executive throughout history (with exception to FDR's New Deal and LBJ's Great Society, both in extraordinary circumstances) have always either been killed or delayed by Congress. Unlike the UK Parliament, where many members usually vote according to their party label, American Congressmen are more prone to break from their party while voting. 60 seats is 60 seats, but it is not 60 votes. The failure to pass a universal healthcare bill could be because of a much stronger American legislature.
From McCarthyism to the Korean and Vietnam wars, America has been known for its hardline stance on communism and socialism and their policies. Some of those on the American right believe a system such as England's NHS as socialist, some even describing it as 'Marxist'. While the Labour Party describes itself as 'social-democratic', and was clearly much further to the left than it is now, the NHS as an institution has the approval of those on the left and also on the right. Perhaps it's America's reluctance to accept seemingly socialist ideas that acts as an obstacle for universal healthcare.
If universal healthcare fails to pass for a second time in America, are those who elected Obama going to feel let-down? What is going to happen to his popularity, which is around the 55% mark, far lower than the high 60s he was receiving earlier in the year? Would the Democrats suffer like they did in 1994? Would Obama get re-elected like Clinton did in '96? Universal healthcare and the welfare state made Clement Attlee's legacy as one of the greatest British Prime Ministers in history, is universal healthcare going to make President Barack Obama great? If the healthcare bill fails to pass, would Obama be seen as a Jimmy Carter-type figure? If the healthcare bill fails to pass now, would universal healthcare ever be an option in America?
Only time will tell...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment